Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Immigration from the Former Soviet Union-A Closer Look

Since Germany’s refugee laws were opened up to Jews in 1990, Jewish immigration from the former Soviet Union has changed and renewed the face of Jewish communities all over Germany. This renewal is perhaps most visible in Berlin, Germany’s capital, which has the largest community of Jews in Germany. It is estimated that approximately 170,000-200,000 Jews from the former Soviet Union have immigrated to Germany since 1990. In Berlin specifically, due to immigration from the former Soviet Union, the number of Jews registered in the Community has jumped from 6,000 in 1989 to around 11,000 in 2010, and many more live in Berlin who are not registered members of the official Community.

Whereas Jews living in the former Soviet Union often faced considerable anti-Semitism, nationality conflicts, economic issues, and an unstable future, Germany’s relaxed immigration laws, its economic prosperity, central location in Europe, as well as its growing Jewish community, have made it an attractive destination for these immigrants. Berlin in particular, Germany’s largest and perhaps most diverse city, has emerged as a new hub for Jewish life.

Still assimilation into German society is not an easy process, though many try to embrace the challenges. A key barrier for immigrants from the former Soviet Union arriving in Germany is that they often do not speak the language, which can alienate them from society at large. For Adults to learn German, they have to take language courses in addition to earning a living and taking care of one’s family—a difficult load to manage. Andre Lossin, managing director of the Jewish Community in Berlin explains that it can be an obstacle to speak only Russian. “Language is the key… because it gives you communication with the people around you.” Thus the German language exists as both a barrier that can make integration more difficult and as a primary requirement of assimilating immigrants into German society.

Another major challenge for first generation immigrants is obtaining careers similar to those they had pursued in the former Soviet Union. Dr. Anne-Margarete Brenker, head of administration at the Abraham Geiger Kolleg, a liberal rabbinical seminary in Berlin, explains that many of the degrees first generation immigrants had acquired during the time they resided in the former Soviet Union are not seen as equivalent to German degrees. As a result, immigrants are often forced to settle for work that requires far fewer skills than they actually possess, says Dr Brenker, adding that these positions are generally not as well paid and less prestigious than the positions they held in the former Soviet Union.

Students at Olam, a Jewish Youth Center in Berlin, describe the process of immigration as one that can make practicing Judaism difficult. When a person moves to Germany, the government determines the exact location where the family is required to move. Anna Perlina, a PhD student at the Max Plank Institut in Berlin, who moved to Germany from the former Soviet Union when she was eleven years old, explains that the German government looks at the economic situation of German cities to determine which ones are financially equipped to service new immigrants. The German government does so to avoid overwhelming individual communities and spread immigrants more evenly across the country. According to teenagers from the Youth Center, some immigrants are assigned to small cities with in some cases barely existing Jewish communities. Many of these towns have no synagogues, Jewish schools or other Jewish institutions, making practicing one’s faith difficult. After seven years however, immigrants are allowed to move freely within Germany and relocate to bigger cities. Berlin is a popular choice because of its diverse and large Jewish community, as well as accessibility to Jewish institutions.

To counter the difficulties of immigration, there are many measures in place. Andre Lossin, managing director of the Jewish Community in Berlin, explains that the Community offers a variety of integration and language courses that are intended to make the transition less stressful. To combat unemployment, for example, there are frequent meetings for the Russian-Jewish community in Berlin to find its members job opportunities. The Jewish Youth Center, which organizes weekly programs and get-togethers, welcomes children with Russian backgrounds and also provides a venue for immigrants to foster their traditions with events focused on the arts and language. The Youth Center offers hip-hop dance, fashion and design, singing and gymnastics classes as well as provides children with the weekly opportunity to learn about their Jewish heritage in a hands-on manner every Sunday afternoon.

In general, the children of immigrants who were born and raised in Germany are managing assimilation more easily than their parents or grandparents who were more closely tied to the former Soviet Union. There are several reasons why second generation immigrants are better at managing this transition. For one thing, children, regardless of their individual backgrounds, are required to learn the German language in the German school system. Though Russian is also offered at some schools, it is an elective course that can only be taken in addition to German. Despite this, some teenagers report having problems learning German because it is not the language spoken at home. But for many teenagers in Berlin, the Jewish high school, youth center, and other Jewish institutions, are places where teens of various Jewish backgrounds can come together, socialize and learn from one another, making integration and learning from one another easier.

Some teenagers living in Berlin report that speaking Russian in Germany can be extremely advantageous. These teenagers believe that having this background makes them more knowledgeable about other cultures than people who have a German background only. It also gives them a connection to other non-Jewish Russian immigrants living in Germany.

There are some Jewish people living in Berlin who find the influx of immigrants from the former Soviet Union to be discouraging them from joining the official Jewish Community in Berlin. These individuals find that these immigrants have brought with them a different language and traditions that distract from the authenticity of Judaism in Berlin. Even though these people have concerns about some of the effects of these immigrants influencing the Jewish Community in Berlin, none can deny that such immigration has had a profound effect on the community,

Jewish Immigrants to Germany are faced with a conflict all immigrants are facing. They may not want to lose touch with the culture they grew up in but may feel a need to assimilate. Many families feel the pressure to surrender some of their traditions, both Jewish and non-Jewish, for the purpose of integration. On the other hand, many immigrants come to Germany with little knowledge about their religious traditions and are now able to openly practice their Jewish faith for the first time since Jewish life in the former Soviet Union was much more restricted. Dr. Benker explains that many immigrants had no strong relationship to their Jewish heritage. “It was not possible because there were no facilities, there was no synagogue, there was no rabbi, there was no Jewish background, there was no kosher food, there was no idea of festivals. It was a completely different picture.” As a result they had re-find their connection to Judaism. “They had to re-find it, not relearn it,” Dr. Brenker emphasizes. “They had to re-find it and that is of course very difficult.” The challenge for these immigrants is to balance the integration process and maintain the traditions unique to their Russian heritage.

Jewish immigrants from the former Soviet Union have changed the Jewish community in Berlin but the community has also changed them. While some immigrants have found assimilation into German society difficult, others have welcomed the challenge with open arms. Becoming part of a community to which a person is not native is always a give and take process, and both immigrants and the Jewish German community itself have responsibilities they must complete in order to be accommodating to the other party. Though integration has not been a seamless process, the influx in immigrants from the former Soviet Union has given Judaism in Berlin a new face that seemed impossible following the Holocaust and the destruction of the German Jewish community during the Nazi regime.


Thursday, July 8, 2010

Modern Jewish Art in Berlin- More Memorials (Extra)

The following two memorials were created before my selected time period (1990-2010); however, I think that they should be noted here because they have very compelling messages.

Ingeborg Hunzinger’s Block of Women was created in memory of the 1943 Rosenstrasse protest in which non-Jewish wives demanded the return of their Jewish husbands who had been arrested for deportation. The
memorial, created by Ingeborg Hunzinger in the mid-1980s, has many Jewish symbols carved into it, and can now be viewed in a park near the original location of the protest in Berlin.






Once you look closely at this face, you will notice that the eyes are shut. This is not to portray peace and harmony. In fact, it means that during the Nazi era many people kept their eyes shut to their surroundings, the atrocities that were committed around them, and did nothing to stop the Holocaust. This cannot happen again.




Fritz Cremer created his sculpture Müttergruppe (Mothers Group) out of bronze. This piece is in memory to all of the mothers and their children who suffered in Ravensbrück, a concentration camp for women. Over 130,000 women and children were held in the camp, and many tens of thousands were killed, starved to death, or were subjected to horrific medical experiments, including forced abortions. The memorial was officially unveiled in 1965 and is located along the street leading to the site of the former concentration camp.








Sunday, July 4, 2010

Jewish Cultural Identity in Berlin Interviews Part 4

Alexander Raev


University Student and Member of the German Israeli Society


Age 25


Non-Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“Berliner and European”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


“There are so many different definitions of Jewish in Berlin like religion or ethnic so it’s really different... Jews from Russia see themselves differently than someone who has always been living in Germany, so there is not one definition of what it means to be Jewish. Jewish can be very German, it can be Russian, or it can be something completely different.”





Anna Perlina


PhD Student, Max Planck Institut


Age 27


Jewish


Born in Ukraine


Moved to Germany at age 11, and to Berlin in 2008



How would you define your cultural identity?


“Cosmopolitan”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"My Jewish identity is for me more just some cultural belonging and some values like education for example... I moved here not because I’m Jewish, but just because I like the city."





Dervis Hizarci


Member of the German Israeli Society


Age 26


Non-Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“Muslim”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"I think today Berlin is pretty nice; a wonderful city, an interesting city, where people from different countries and cultures and religions can live very well together. So I think it is also nice for a Jew to live in Berlin."




Kerstin von der Krone


PhD Student, Jewish Studies, and Member of the German Israeli Society


Age 31


Non-Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“German and European”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"I guess there is still a complicated situation because you have all this history: the history of the community of Berlin which is within Jewish history one of the most important communities, as well as the German-Jewish history of the Holocaust. But I guess it is better because people are not as questioned anymore as they were, like as Jews who live in Germany. Today it's more the story of the success of a flourishing community."




Caspar Schwalbe


University Student and Member of the German Israeli Society


Age 22


Jewish background on father's side of family


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“European”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"The history pretty much shapes the entire politics of today. If you look at a speech of the chancellor or any open speech of any high representative the history is always a very important part. Even if [Angela Merkel] doesn't speak about it, the way she is pronouncing words or putting words together is all a product [of history]... Germany has realized how good it is to step up to the responsibility and to openly show that we can move on, that it is better to face it and accept it and realize the full commitment than to hide it... ... It can make you more proud than any nationalistic or patriotic pride can give you in Germany. If they put up these flags and so on it's not giving you the same pride as if you realize there is a genuine approach to it.

"My generation is the last that actually has some link. My grandparents are the last people who were actively involved in the war... they have this extreme last link that we will be the last to witness. And what is after us? How will our children or the youngsters today grow up with it? What will they take from it?"

Jewish Cultural Identity in Berlin Interviews Part 3

Barbara Kurowska


Tour Guide at the Memorial to the Murdered Jews in Berlin


Age 26


Non-Jewish


Born in Poland


Moved to Berlin 2008



How would you define your cultural identity?


“When I’m in Berlin I can feel very Polish, but in Poland I can feel very close to Germany”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"I think it means on the one hand dealing with the difficult history that you stumble upon every corner in Berlin. It's the heritage of what you're dealing with, but at the same time it's this vibrant, lively city that you're in and just people from so many different backgrounds and so many different cultures that live here. I think it's combining all of those things and finding your own little place. I think there is room for everyone in Berlin these days."




Julia Paehler


English Teacher at the Jewish High School (Juedische Oberschule) in Berlin


Age 36


Non-Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“German”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"I think they have very close connections... We have a growing Jewish life here in Berlin [with] lots of opportunities for the people to meet. And I think it's quite a vivid Jewish life here in Berlin and it's getting more and more [so]."




Dr. Anne-Margarete Brenker


Head of Administration at the Abraham Geiger Kolleg, a liberal rabbinical seminary


Non-Jewish


Born in Ukraine


Moved to Berlin 1998



How would you define your cultural identity?


“I can’t say”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"It is very different living as a Jew in Berlin or in Germany because you always live against the cycle. You have your own cycle, but it is another one than the majority of people has... I personally think it must be very difficult and I have a big admiration for people who really are able to live within a completely different rhythm."




Solvejg Franke


Opera Director


Age 36


Jewish


Born in Germany


Moved to Berlin in 2009



How would you define your cultural identity?


“European Jewish”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"I live here. I'm looking for Jews here in Berlin and it's sometimes difficult to find Jews. It is not so easy to find the different Jewish groups and to connect with them."

Saturday, June 26, 2010

Modern Jewish Art in Berlin- Jewish Museum Berlin













Photograph by Suzanne Lettrick

Daniel Libeskind's architectural design of the Jewish Museum in Berlin, named "Between the Lines" refers to the shape of the buildings as seen from above, resembling a deconstructed Star of David. It symbolizes the tensions of German-Jewish history, and causes the visitor to emotionally react to and reflect upon the design of the museum. The Jewish Museum in Berlin opened in September 2001, fifty six years after the end of Nazi Germany.

Modern Jewish Art in Berlin- Art Show Interviews


SILVIA DZUBAS

What drew you to Berlin as an artist?
"I was born here [in East Berlin]."

Is there something about Berlin that inspires your art?
"No."

Do you think that your jewish identity is always or sometimes incorporated into you art? How?
"Yes!...my father was from a concentration camp, so you [can't really ignore that]... jewish history [is an influence]. "

What is Jewish art?
"[We are all] human beings...Art is so free that there is not a jewish style. That's bullshit. [There are] colors...and [art is] emotional."




NORMA DRIMMER

What drew you to Berlin as an artist?
"I was born in Berlin after the [second world] war."

Is there something about Berlin that inspires your art?
"I have seen all of the historical events..."

Do you think that your jewish identity is always or sometimes incorporated into you art? How?
"Not specifically Jewish...You are somewhat informed from where you come from."




DEBORA GUTMAN

What drew you to Berlin as an artist?
"I was born here."

Is there something about Berlin that inspires your art?
"No."

Do you think that your jewish identity is always or sometimes incorporated into you art? How?
"Not really...there are some words."

What is Jewish art?
"The way I paint and the way I see the world [can be Jewish]...but I am just human...[it is] artistic."




DAFNA GROSSMAN

What drew you to Berlin as an artist?
"I came because Berlin was honest...it is ugly and beautiful at the same time...and not static....without ugliness there is no beauty; and without beauty there is no ugliness."

Is there something about Berlin that inspires your art?
"I am a photographer, so I use locations."

Do you think that your jewish identity is always or sometimes incorporated into you art? How?
"More my Israeli identity...I moved two years ago."

What is Jewish art?
"Also a Christian can make Jewish art...[But] just because it is a star of David does not mean it is Jewish art."

Friday, June 25, 2010

Jewish Cultural Identity in Berlin Interviews Part 2

Dalia Grinfeld


Student at the Jewish High School (Juedische Oberschule) in Berlin


Age 15


Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“German, but a very Jewish German”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"I think it is not hard [to be Jewish in Berlin] anymore... I live my way, I go my way and I don't have problems because I’m Jewish. … Actually in Berlin, you have [some Muslim] areas you can’t go… But I’m not there so I don't have these problems.

"[Non-Jews] don't know us, they don't know Jew in Berlin... and so you are something special, you are something very, very special. They all say 'Wow, you are Jewish! You're the first Jew I know! Wow! Can I ask you questions?’... They are German and just German and most of them are Christian and they have their own community in Berlin."



German Navoyenko

Student at the Jewish High School (Juedische Oberschule) in Berlin


Age 16


Jewish


Born in Ukraine


Moved to Berlin 1998




How would you define your cultural identity?


“German”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"It is a big honor because I have the possibility to do something new, to show the world how Jewish people live in Germany... Many, many people are thinking 'ok Jewish people living in Germany - how could they do this because of what happened 60 years ago?' and we have to show to the world how to act with some people like [the Nazis]... and to show the [rest of the Jewish world] that we are Jewish just like they are."





Esther Smith

High School Student in Berlin


Age 17


Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“Jewish German”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


“I think it's good that I’m living here because somebody needs to... build the Judaism up here more…We're getting really strong now. [But] a lot of people are [still] not coming back because of the Holocaust, but I think it’s right to live here because it should be developed."


Nataniel Satanowski

High School Student in Berlin


Age 17


Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“Jewish”


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


"I think the Jewish life should go on in Berlin where Nazi Germany had the power 65 years ago. I think it is important that there are Jews in Germany.”


David Wainstejn

Student at the Jewish High School (Juedische Oberschule) in Berlin


Age 17


Jewish


Born in Germany



How would you define your cultural identity?


“half Israeli, half German, and all Jewish


What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?


“Nothing. It's just I am [a] Jew living in Berlin... it's just normal...You always have anti-Semitism in every country, in every city, so it's easier if you have your own background, you have your own friends… Because in my opinion... when you have a connection [with someone] not just because you're friends… it's closer."



Lily Smith

High School Student in Berlin

Age 17

Jewish

Born in Germany


How would you define your cultural identity?

“Believer”

What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?

"[Being Jewish] means a lot to me... [I feel I have a] duty to do it because [I] just want to keep it alive and…want to do so much for it to keep it strong."


Sharon Bajda

Student at the Jewish High School (Juedische Oberschule) in Berlin

Age 14

Jewish

Born in Germany


How would you define your cultural identity?

“Jewish German”

What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?

"I mostly have Jewish friends, my community is Jewish, my best friend is Jewish, my mom [and] my dad are Jewish, so I am [also] Jewish."



David Ohayon

Student at the Jewish High School in Berlin

Age 17

Jewish

Born in Germany


How would you define your cultural identity?

“Jewish German bound to Israel”

What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?

"I think it doesn’t matter if I am Jewish living in Germany because of course there is some big history here in Germany, but I think we have to move on and not be stuck in remembering stuff about things that happened to us. [Instead we need to] just to go on and be open here to Germany and to find how to make [our] life here and stay happy."



Alina Putilin

Student at the Jewish High School in Berlin

Age 15

Jewish

Born in Germany


How would you define your cultural identity?

“Jewish kid that lives in Germany”

What does it mean to be Jewish in Berlin today?

"I live my whole life [in Germany]... I have different friends: Jewish friends and not Jewish friends but there isn’t a difference."